WauwatosaNOW.com
search all things local
     
Blog Home |        Welcome to MyCommunityNOW - Blogs Sign in | Join

Hunting Season

I've lived and worked in the Falls for many years. If they moved Miller Park to Appleton and Good Hope, I don't think I'd ever have to leave the village again.

The Star Spangled Banner - no "showboating". PLEASE!

By William Weaver
Monday, Sep 29 2008, 11:07 PM

If you're a long-suffering Brewers fan, a "mid-term" suffering Brew Crew believer, or even a bandwagon jumper; was this last weekend (when The Crew won their way into the wildcard spot) freakin' sweet or what?  Good stuff!

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Not to "chill the good vibes", but there has been something grinding my gears this whole season.  The National Anthem singers/players "showboating" their talent to the detriment of "The Star Spangled Banner".

Let me ask you this, performers: Is your role to showcase your talent, or to lead the crowd in the singing of the National Anthem? 

In my opinion, it should be the latter, and the Brewers organization should make that clear, effective immediately.

If you're singing/playing the national anthem solo at Miller Park, you CAN sing/play.  We get that.  They don't give tone deaf/predominantly wavering pitch performers the mic/headset at Miller Park for the national anthem these days.

But don't "showboat" your talent.  Sing/play the song straight up.  None of that "Lay-und of the Freeeeeeee-EEEEEEeeeee-EEEEEHHHHH!HHHHHHHHHHH!!!!" stuff from the singers.  And none of those "I should sooooooo be the star of smooth jazz radio" runs on your solo wind instrument.

Learn a lesson from the middle school bands that played before Friday's (9/26) game, or any choir that has performed the anthem at Miller Park. 

Perform the song straight up, so that those of us in the crowd can sing along.

It's about US, not YOU.


 

Me? For what now?

By William Weaver
Tuesday, Sep 9 2008, 07:52 PM

The Missus played back the phone messages for me this evening.  I had a "robo-call" and perhaps a "real call" from Assembly candidates in my district.  Or did I?   You tell me...

Let's clear the air, shall we?

I'll put all the WI - 24th Assembly "dirty tricks", "robo-calls", "direct mail shenanigans", "etc. and so forth" , on myself.

Why?

I am the guy.  I'm THE guy, and I'm running for EVERYTHING.

My platform?  Do unto others as you will do unto yourself.

If you've voted in the Falls for a while, you know there is always a "write-in" spot for every office.

And if you need a name to write-in, let me spell it out for you:

WILLIAM WEAVER

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

UPDATE: Election night, 7:45 p.m. -

What had started as a rant after I was pumped up after a Packers win (and a heck of a lot of beer while watching the game - seriously folks, don't drink and blog...) has turned into a widespread grassroots movement for change!  Or more of the same!  Depends on the issue, y'know.

I spent literally minutes campaigning at work today.  I told the voters "if there's an uncontested race, write me in.  But there's already some good candidates running for Assembly and Congress, so I won't take it personally if you actually vote for someone on the ballot in those cases".

So now it's just a matter of waiting to get the the congratulatory call(s) from the County Clerk (which is a position I'm running for, along with District Attorney and a few others - I forget all of them, but I'll do a hell of a job at any/all of them, believe you me), and the concession calls from my surprised opponents, who this morning all thought they were running unopposed.

Polls are almost closed.  Got to clear the phone line and make ready the celebration!

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

UPDATE - Election Night, 8:30 p.m. -

Only one call so far, and it was from the Missus.  I told her we were out of bread & milk.  Her response: "why didn't you pick some up on your way home from work?"  Guess who just talked herself out of a cushy government job, missy?

Seriously though, I thought the voice mail I had from the Knodl campaign yesterday was a fake.  A plant from a graduate of the Atwater/Rove school of dirty campaigning.  That belief (along with the Packers win and, yes, vitamin B[eer]) fueled my post last night.  But then I surfed by Dan's site tonight and there was an announcement that was almost verbatim what was on my voice mail.  Whoops - my bad.  I hope Dan names who the marketing firm was so I can be sure to NEVER hire them!

Back to the phone...

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

UPDATE - Election Night, 10:45 p.m. -

Still no call.  I guess they'll just wait until tomorrow morning then?  Not a problem.  I can wait a few more hours before going into general campaign mode.  And lest I forget, thanks to all y'all who wrote me in.  YOU are what makes this country great!

I was following the results on JSOnline (who were taking their sweet time updating results, hey?  How could the same race with the same wards reporting have different reporting percentages depending on the party?), and it looks like Knodl v. Brady for the 24th.  Pretty tight race on the Republican side.  Maybe I'll reconsider hiring Dan's marketing firm.

Brewers in extra innings, but it's time for bed.  More hard-hitting election action as it develops!

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

FINAL UPDATE - Wed. 9/10, 6:45 p.m. -

Well, I didn't win anything.  That may come as a surprise to a few of you.  I'm still working on getting over it myself.  But to those citizens who took the time to write my name in for any race, thank you so much!

In my nearly 24-hour-long campaign, I did learn a few things: (1) You don't do these things on a whim.  It takes planning, time, and a lot of work.  (2)  You may not like all of the people running, you may not agree with their positions, but you should respect the time, effort, and sacrifice of anyone running for any public office.  Even in the smallest local race, you're under the microscope of John Q. Public, subject to the knives of the "blogosphere", and can get unjustly smeared from almost any source.  (Ok, I knew these things before, but I've taken the time to reflect on them over the last few days).

My respect to those who took up the challenge.

Filed under:
Permalink |  Mail to a friend

 

A choice for the 5th Congressional District

By William Weaver
Wednesday, Sep 3 2008, 07:54 PM

When you go to cast your ballot in the September 9th primary, you'll see more than one name on the Republican side for Wisconsin's 5th Congressional District. 

One name you already know.  It's been on the ballot for almost 30 years.  Most times, even in the general election, it's been the only name on the ballot for Congress in the 5th.

The other name, however, may be new to you if you don't follow these things.  Or maybe you haven't seen the red & white yard signs that are springing up throughout the district that start with the statement "NOT A CAREER POLITICIAN".

The name of that "David" versus the entrenched "Goliath" is Jim Burkee.  You can read more about Jim Burkee, why he's running, and even see the video of the debate he had versus the long-time incumbent by clicking on the link attached to Mr. Burkee's name in the previous sentence.  (I've read, courtesy of fellow bloggers, that the debate is also available on the "Wisconsin Eye"  channel 1111 on TW Cable).  If you prefer the "Reader's Digest version" of many of the main points, Jim wrote an interesting blog post for MequonNOW a few weeks back.

I realize the easy, comfortable thing to do is to keep voting for the same person over and over.  But you owe it to yourself as a citizen to take a look at what the challenger has to say, and then make an informed decision on whom to vote for.

And, of course, get out there and vote!


 

The 24th Assembly district candidates: In their own words

By William Weaver
Monday, Aug 18 2008, 10:05 PM

In a recent post I asked the candidates running for Wisconsin's 24th Assembly district to "justify my vote".  On August 6th I contacted all six declared candidates via e-mail or the contact form on their respective websites and sent them this message: 

 

“Hello -

My name is William Weaver, and I'm both a Menomonee Falls and 24th Assembly district resident.

 

I would like to ask you a single question re: your candidacy for the WI State Assembly, and post your response in the blog I write for MenomoneeFallsNOW.com (http://blogs.menomoneefallsnow.com/hunting_season/).

 

Your reply will be printed verbatim, without any editorial comments on my part.  I'm putting the deadline for responses at Noon on Monday August 18th, 2008 and I plan to post the replies I've received either that evening or the next day.

 

My question is: Why should I (and by extension other voters in the 24th Assembly district) vote for you during the primary on September 9th, 2008?

 

I look forward to your response, and my best to you in your campaign!

 Regards -William Weaver, Menomonee Falls, WI” I have to say I was pleasantly surprised at the number of responses I received!  I'm posting the responses in the order that I received them.   Disclosure notice on my formatting: (1) I have added the candidate’s name in bold caps before their respective responses.  (2) I “cut and pasted” the replies from their e-mails, and (3) I have tried to alter the fonts and alignment of paragraphs to be uniform, though my attempts to make the format pleasing to the eye have been a trial (to put it mildly).  Know that these folks know how to construct a paragraph! If any of the candidates have issues with this formatting, let me know a.s.a.p. and I’ll update this post with your original font/paragraph alignment. Let’s get to it!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

RANDY MELCHERT

 Hello!

The Wisconsin State Assembly, while often overlooked, passes binding laws on the entire state. It is important that the candidate elected be qualified for this position. I believe that the best qualified candidate should have the ABC's down: Academic Credentials, Business Experience, and Conservative Leadership.

I believe education is important, and that Academic Credentials are valuable, and that is why I am a lifelong learner. After completing high school in three years, and graduating from college, I graduated with a Master's Degree from Trinity International University. I am also working on a second Master's Degree in Communication. Of all the candidates running on either party, I am the only candidate with a postgraduate degree.

Business experience is an essential aspect of qualified governmental candidates. I am a radio station owner, and understand the challenges affecting business today. When I put together a team to purchase the station, it was struggling with older technology and a negative cash flow. I was able to modernize the equipment, lower energy costs 50%, increase listeners 300% by testing various formats, and have restored the station to profitability. Right now we are leasing time to a community organization that is in the process of purchasing that station.

In addition to the Academic Credentials and Business Experience, it is also important to have a record of Conservative Leadership. While other candidates will say they support conservative values, it is important to look at their record. I am the first candidate to publish my Taxpayer Protection Pledge - I believe the future of Wisconsin's economic success is dependent on lower taxes. I am 100% Pro-Life, and worked to recall Senator Feingold over his support of the Partial-Birth Abortion ban, a procedure so gruesome that no group that condones that procedure can call itself civilized. I believe in traditional marriage, and worked to help pass the Marriage Amendment in Wisconsin in 2006. I support the 2nd Amendment, and am a Hunters Education graduate. If voters are looking for someone who doesn't just share their views but has worked to advance their views, then please check out my website.

While the candidate must be qualified, he must also understand his community. I am a lifelong, 5th generation Menomonee Falls resident. My great-great-grandfather moved here from North Dakota, to seek a better opportunity, and worked as a janitor at Menomonee Falls High School. My great-grandmother ran a cafe near the corner of Appleton & Main Street. My grandfather's law office is near that same corner. My mother marched in the band that opened the "super-wide" Appleton Avenue. This community is not just my home, it's my family tree.

Finally, voters should look for someone with tangible goals that can be communicated and measured. I have been promoting The Melchert Plan (www.themelchertplan.com) as a way where by eliminating the minimum markup law, reformulated gas, and lowering our gas tax to the national average we can all benefit from cutting gas prices 10%. For more information or to calculate your own savings please visit www.themelchertplan.com.

Thank you for this opportunity!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

 

JASON LASAGE

 

Republican voters have to choose between four conservative candidates that all want to lower taxes, reign in government spending, and build a strong business climate in our state through incentives, less taxation, and less regulation.  Though, what makes me stand out among the Republican candidates is experience and a track record that proves I am deserving of trust.   

 

I have the most experience in government, through serving as vice-president and 6 years on the Germantown School Board, where I helped oversee a 36 million dollar budget and from working for state Senator Alberta Darling’s office.   

 

I have experience in business through working my entire life in Menomonee Falls, first at Guaranty Bank, then at Strong Investments as a licensed securities representative.  I also own a self-made real estate portfolio which has taught me how to budget, prioritize, and perform cost benefit analysis, similar to when I work with individual clients to help them purchase a home or make an investment decision and akin to what needs to happen in state government.  

 

I have experience in education, from not only the school board, but through tutoring area kids and part-time substitute teaching for the past 6 years at Thomas Jefferson, North Jr. High, and Menomonee Falls High School.  Nearly half of the state budget deals with education; from day one I will have a hands-on, working knowledge of many of our expenditures. 

 

I also have community experience, from being a life-long 24th district resident, growing up in Germantown and currently living as a Menomonee Falls homeowner.  I have actively served on many community boards including: Youth Futures, Deutschstadt Heritage Foundation, Leadership Germantown, and the Washington County Republican Party Board.  I have also been involved in numerous volunteer projects in Menomonee Falls and Germantown. 

 

These experiences, along with my family upbringing, have shaped who I am.  Voters can trust that I understand their hard-working, low tax and spending values.  They can trust that I understand that the community wants a representative who respects life and believes that those who do us harm should be locked up rather than given liberal “understanding.”  

 

Madison is in need of great change if we are to get out of being ranked 46th among the states in job creation.   Since I am the only candidate that has fundamentally changed a governmental body, through taking 6-1 votes where I was in the lonely minority, voters can trust that I am the right person to represent them in the state assembly.  I educated the community on what was happening in their schools and we packed gymnasiums with people demanding change.  Together we succeeded.  Voters deserve someone who will stand up to special interest groups, political pressure, intimidation, money and promises of power.  I have done this at the local level and I am ready to tackle a new challenge.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

 

DAN KNODL

Of all the candidates I am the only Father of children. I understand the responsibility we have as legislators to keep Wisconsin healthy and strong now and into the future. Unfortunately our recent legislators have been shirking this responsibility. My unique combination of being a Dad, long term business ownership and current elected experience give me the tools and knowledge needed to be an effective Assembly Representative. I am not interested in partisan politics and political posturing...I want to go to Madison to get the peoples business done. We need to get our financial house in order...NOW! We cannot continue to accumulate debt that will become an overwhelming burden upon our children and grandchildren. We need experienced business people that can make the difficult and often unpopular decisions necessary to get Wisconsin back on track to being a truly great State. I am not interested in being popular...I am interested in being effective. My opponents simply do not have the age and experience needed to be effective immediately. I already have working relationships with several current legislators and we can get down to business quickly. As a 23 year business owner(Reef Point Resort, Pike Lake) I have been successful in budgeting, meeting payroll, and customer satisfaction.  These are things that are sorely needed in Madison. As a father of four I understand the burden of raising children and preparing financially for their futures. We need leadership that can and will prepare(and repair) Wisconsin's financial future.


As a current elected official(2nd term on Washington County Board) I understand the back room workings of government and I can dismiss the overtures of operatives looking to advance their personal agendas at the expense of others.


Its time for the game playing in Madison to end.


We need to get on with responsible governance for Wisconsin residents.

I offer years of experience, responsibility and dedication to getting the job done. I can and will be an effective legislator for the people of the 24th district.
I ask for their vote.  

Dan Knodl
www.danknodl.com
dknodl@yahoo.com
262-707-7805

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

 

MICHAEL MOSCICKE

 

Dear William,

I am the candidate of experience.  I have more experience with the state government than any of the other candidates running in this race.  For the past three years I've worked for the state Department of Administration in the state capitol building.  As a tour guide I was responsible for teaching the general public about what the legislature does and who they are, giving me more first hand knowledge about how the legislature operates and more connections in the legislature than any of my opponents.  I've worked for the state Department of Health Services as an office manager, which provides me with an inside view of how one of the largest state departments functions and how the private health care sector currently interacts with the state.  I've also served on the faculty senate of the thirteen statewide University of Wisconsin Colleges, during which I sat on over 20 different committee that dealt issues ranging from curriculum to multimillion dollar budgets.

I understand how businesses benefit from less government intervention and fewer fees, which is why I'm supported by the Greater Milwaukee Association of Realtors. 

I know the community.  I was born in Menomonee Falls and my parents and grandparents grew up right here and in Germantown
 

I may not be the oldest candidate, but I am older than Tommy Thompson was when he was first elected to the State Assembly, and that turned out pretty well. 

I have reliable values.  It's common in elections for candidates to promise things they can't deliver and this election is no different.  You're going to hear over and over that if elected a candidate is going to lower your taxes, ensure you have free healthcare or make the state more business friendly.  None of these things can be accomplished by only one representative.  Any viable legislation will have to be passed out of committee, voted on by 131 other legislators and signed by a Governor, who for at least the next two years will be a Democrat.  I've worked with these Representatives, Senators and Governor for the past three years.  I know how to convey to them what's most important to me and the community I come from.  This is why promises are not important, but values are.  When it comes to hammering out a budget or any legislation, the other legislators won't care what I promised to get elected.  Instead they're going to care about what's best for Wisconsin, what really matters to the people who live in the community and what negotiating can be done to get a real law passed.  That said, here is what I believe in: I believe that the state government needs to be smaller, 53,000 state employees are far too many.  I believe that taxes in Wisconsin are too high, especially when it comes to the fees that keep skyrocketing every time we pass a budget simply because no one wants to admit they're really a tax.  I believe that education in Wisconsin should be accessible to everyone and that it makes no sense to have a state run University if most people can't afford to pay the tuition it charges.  I believe that we can solve the problem of rising health care costs without socializing the health care industry.  I believe that government should not tell people how to live their lives. 

I have a plan.  Any effective legislator must begin by hiring a skilled legislative aide, who does a great deal of the constituent relations work, legislative research and other day to day operations in the capitol building office.  My first choice to fill this role would be Sue Jeskewitz's current legislative aide, Diane Handrick, who has played a key role in keeping things in Representative Jeskewitz's office running smoothly and successfully over the last few years.  I immediately plan to keep my individual office budget low by not requesting state highway maps for distribution and not sending out any mailings to constituents, both of which are often state sponsored campaign materials.  I plan on asking for committee seats on the Colleges and Universities committee, the Elections and Constitutional Law Committee, and the Public Health Committee.  These positions would help me push forward legislation that would reform the public University of Wisconsin System, eliminate the positions of state Treasurer and Secretary of State, and implement partnerships with the private health sector that will reduce the costs of health care and make health care more accessible to everyone. 

Finally, I'm committed to continuing Sue Jeskewitz's record of ethical, informed service in the state legislature.  This is the most important reason a vote for me is the best vote. 

Sincerely,
Michael Moscicke

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

 

CHARLENE BRADY

 

Thanks for the opportunity to get my message out.  I am The Frugal Choice.  I will not be spending thousands of dollars to buy myself a job with insurance better than most of the residents of this district have. I am knocking on doors to introduce myself and get to know the people I'll be representing.

I'm running because I have the leadership and experience required to move past partisan politics to find solutions that will strengthen Wisconsin's economy, bring efficiency to government, and ensure economic growth through education.

Experience includes serving on the Washington County Board of Supervisors for three terms, the Germantown Village Board and numerous committees.  Besides being a civil engineer, I've also worked in retail, in a restaurant, as a quality control assistant director in manufacturing, a ski instructor, and a lead buyer for a book company.  Life experience includes being married to the same person 28 years and raising three children.

Besides helping out in the schools and being involved in several school groups and activities throughout the years I've been involved in many community activities including the Menomonee Falls Newcomers Club, Friends of the Library, Civil Air Patrol and the Germantown Tourism and Betterment Committee. 

Engineers find solutions to problems and moms take care of children, I'm an engineer and a mom with experience.  I'll look out for all my residents.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So there you have it.  The 24th Assembly district candidates, in their own words.  My thanks to the candidates for taking the time to respond!

Remember folks, Tuesday September 9th is the primary.  Get out there and vote!


 

24th Assembly district candidates - justify my vote!

By William Weaver
Wednesday, Aug 6 2008, 09:25 PM

Straight up - why should I vote for you during our primary on September 9th, 2008?

I'll e-mail the candidates who I can find e-mail addresses on within the next few days (since your staffers are probably busy with other things than reading my blog here - lol!) to give everyone a chance to speak.  (UPDATE 8/6/08 - all six candidates have been contacted either via e-mail or the contact form on their website). 

I'll put the cutoff date for responses at Noon on Monday August 18th, and post your replies soon thereafter.  For those pro-active candidates/staffers, e-mail me here via the "Email author" link in the masthead, but know that I'll perform due diligence to verify it actually came from your campaign.

For those not up on these things, the declared candidates for WI State Assembly, 24th district (links courtesy of JSonline [UPDATE 8/6/08 - links for Michael Moscicke and Charlene S. Brady are new, courtesy of Google.]):

Republican: Dan Knodl, Jason LaSage, Randall Ryan Melchert, Michael Moscicke
Democrat: Charlene S. Brady, Torrey Lauer

I look forward to hearing from all y'all!


 

Freedom of choice

By William Weaver
Wednesday, Jul 23 2008, 09:39 PM

All those yard signs touting candidates for State Assembly district # 24 assure one thing: a spirited September primary!

(Not sure if you're in the 24th Assembly district?  If you live in G-town or Butler, the answer is yes.  Most of Menomonee Falls as well.  To find out for sure, go here).

I think I've got the Republican Assembly candidates sussed pretty well, but here's some links so you can read what they have to say and decide for yourself: Dan Knodl, Jason LaSageRandy Melchert, and Michael Moscicke.  (Note that the links for the first three candidates are from a JSonline article and appear to be their respective official campaign sites.  I googled Michael's name for his link).

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

On the U.S. Congress side, there's an interesting and very unusual development in the race for Wisconsin's 5th district: a new Republican candidate with the stones to take on long-time (nearly 30-year) incumbent Jim Sensenbrenner.  His name?  Jim Burkee.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tuesday Sept. 9th is the day of the primary election, so educate yourself on the candidates and get out there and vote!  For those in the Falls, note that some polling locations have changed.  Primary elections are ideal for first-time voters to register, learn the mechanics of casting a ballot in a "low-pressure environment", and experience the beauty of democracy first-hand.

How can you not love this country?


 

So McCain is now the "environmental" candidate?

By William Weaver
Wednesday, Jul 9 2008, 11:07 PM

As I was watching Brew Crew games on TV the last few days, I was constantly seeing the ad run by the Republican National Committee about how our Republican nominee will combat climate change.  Just what is the RNC thinking here?  I guess next we'll see, what, Sen. McCain's plan for universal healthcare (and at taxpayer expense)?

I've done enough independent observation and study on Presidential political campaigns to confirm that one goes for "the base" in the primaries, and then goes for "the middle" in the general election.  It's worked in the past, and it may work in the present and the future.

But COME ON you folks in the RNC ad dept.!  This is the best you can do in this swing state?


 

A great Brewers weekend

By William Weaver
Sunday, Jun 22 2008, 09:56 PM

We took in two of this weekend's inter-league games vs. the Baltimore Orioles (Sat. & Sun. 6/21-6/22).  Both games were Brewers wins (always fun - for Crew fans!), enough dingers to get the crowd ramped up (in case you haven't heard, Prince Fielder has still got it!), and enough sticky situations (Crew pitching - don't get me started...) to keep the hardcore baseball fans interested.  Two sellouts in a row, two great days of tailgating weather, and two straight giveaways (thanks to those who took their time coming in on Saturday - both the missus and I got a cap).  I also had a personal first on Saturday in seeing the roof start as closed, then open up, then get closed again.

While this will not be news to those of you who have been to Miller Park on a regular basis, Saturday evening games during the summer (especially with nice weather on game day) tend to produce a "more lubricated" crowd than normal.  Sunday afternoon games tend to be more family-friendly, though not always depending on where you sit (I do love affordable bleacher seats, but no way will I seat the family there for a weekend game.  Your results may differ).  We went Loge Diamond this weekend and we had GREAT "seat neighbors" for both games, so the game experience was that much better.

Saturday evening was special from our fan perspective.  A gentleman seated in front of us (in full O's regalia) turned around during the 2nd inning to ask me what Seth McClung's W-L record was (I answered correctly, 4-3 going into that game).  Then an elder gentleman seated to his right struck up a conversation with him about the O's vs. the Crew, and baseball in general, which lasted the entire game.  Great insights by both fans.  The O's fan pointed out to all of us Hall Of Fame pitcher and O's broadcaster Jim Palmer in the visiting broadcast booth (the O's fan already knew where Mr. Baseball was).

All in all, a great Brewers weekend.

--------------------------------------------------------------

On other summer topics, Ted Klumb has a great post about "gentlemen of a certain age" (and then some) who should do us all a favor and COVER IT UP!

Filed under:
Permalink |  Mail to a friend

 

Yet another disgruntled ex-employee? (Part 1)

By William Weaver
Monday, Jun 9 2008, 07:52 PM

(What had started as a short observation has kept getting longer, so I'm going to break this up into two parts.  Part two will be posted within the next few weeks.)

Not quite breaking news any more, but former Bush Administration Press Secretary Scott McClellan has written a book (What Happened: Inside the Bush White House and Washington's Culture of Deception) that has been reported to be critical of the Bush Administration, including the run-up to the invasion of Iraq.  I haven't read the book yet, so I can't comment on the content.  But I do have enough horse sense to know that the most inflammatory quotes, especially if and/or when taken out of context, tend to make the headlines.

One thing I did find peculiar though was the Bush administration's response.  According to them, McClellan is, essentially, a disgruntled ex-employee.

As I was watching and reading some of the media coverage on this, I remembered something like this happening before...

Against All Enemies: Inside America's War on Terror--What Really Happened by former National Security Council Advisor Richard Clarke came out in 2004.  It was critical of the Bush and Clinton Administration's handling of anti-terrorism, and was also critical of the 2003 invasion of Iraq as not really aiding the war on terror.  Clarke had served in varying capacities from the Reagan administration onwards, and began his government career with the Department of Defense in 1973.  While I don't recall any Bush Administration officials stating it directly at the time, the refrain I heard on talk radio and Fox News was that Clarke was, essentially, a disgruntled ex-employee.

Earlier in 2004, The Price of Loyalty: George W. Bush, the White House, and the education of Paul O'Neill by Ron Suskind was released.  The book was based on extensive interviews with the Bush Administration's first Secretary of the Treasury Paul O'Neill, as well as review of essentially every unclassified document that crossed Secretary O'Neill's desk during his tenure in office.  O'Neill took issue with the overall management of the Administration's first two years, as well as the Administration's policy on Iraq (note that this was pre-invasion, as Secretary O'Neill resigned effective 12/31/02).  While O'Neill also has deep roots in government (serving under President's Nixon and Ford, and passing on being Secretary of Defense under George H.W. Bush while recommending Dick Cheney for the job), he also has a long and successful track record as a corporate executive.  Again, while I don't recall any Bush Administration officials stating it directly, I remember the frequent talking point of commentators on talk radio and FNC at the time was that O'Neill was, essentially, a disgruntled ex-employee.

I read both the Suskind and Clarke books within a few months of their respective releases (thanks to the Menomonee Falls Public Library for making them available!).  I heartily recommend the Suskind book as it's a broader view of the management of the Bush Administration's first two years, and especially for Secretary O'Neill's views on fiscal policy (now THERE is a fiscal conservative and realist!).  The Clarke book is a pretty good read though the issue focus is narrower, and his writing seems to be self-serving at times.

Anyway, points to ponder: (1) Does releasing a political book in a hotly contested election year help sales?  (2) If said book has content critical of the invasion of Iraq in retrospect, is it truly newsworthy?  (3) Can all three of these men be, essentially, disgruntled ex-employees?


 
More Posts

 
The opinions and views expressed by Community Voice writers do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Journal Interactive, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel or Community Newspapers. MyCommunityNow.com does not control, is not responsible for, and does not guarantee the accuracy, integrity or quality of, the postings on this Web log. Readers can report objectionable content by clicking here.