WauwatosaNOW.com
search all things local
     
Blog Home |  Email Author  |        Welcome to MyCommunityNOW - Blogs Sign in | Join

The Forum


New Community Survey Results

By Steve Koczela
Saturday, Nov 15 2008, 10:18 AM

I have created a set of crosstabs that show the effect of re-weighting the data with renters represented in their proper proportion of households (just over half the sample). 

DOWNLOAD CROSSTABS.

This reweighting by own vs. rent also brings down overall income levels, since Shorewood renters have a lower income profile than homeowners.   I created these crosstabs relatively quickly (yes, I have a day job), and it is possible I made an error or two, so let me know if you see anything that does not seem right.  I see this as a completely "open source" project (the data is a public record), so let me know if you want to the SPSS files, or the Excel version of the crosstabs.  I am open to suggestions, revisions, criticism, and personal insults, if you would like to participate in this.

Why, Steve?  Is this some sort of methodological crusade you are on?  Some nutty academic exercise?

Not at all.  There is nothing wrong with using unweighted data, especially since part of the intent of the 2008 Community Survey was to track the changes in opinions over time.  However, in this case, using raw responses has the additional effect of discounting the importance of renter households.  I believe it is important to look at Village opinion with renters' opinions given its proper value, proportional to their share of the households in our Village.

There is a lot of interesting data in here, which could make for a great deal of interesting discussion.

As a side note, I weighted to a count of 600, which means renters are weighted at about 1.  Homeowners are weighted down to the proper proportion within a weighted sample of 600.  There is a lot of missing data in individual surveys, so you will notice that the weighted counts bounce around, and never quite reach 600.

Comments

David Tatarowicz   

Steve

I think what you are doing is extremely important.  As has been noted before, the Village Board is elected "at large", and does not represent individual areas of the Village.

Right now, and for some time, all the Village Board members are from the more affluent areas of Shorewood, and in my own opinion, are very much out of touch with the folks on the "other side of the tracks".

I look forward to your continuing work on this project, and would find it very interesting if the demographics could be overlaid against the voting patterns in the Village.  From my very quick glances in the past, it seemed the Lower Income Renter Dominated Western part of Shorewood voted more conservatively than the Higher Income Easterners did.

Good to see you back in the trenches.

Dave

November 16, 2008 3:58 PM

Steve Koczela   

Hi Dave -

Unfortunately, geography was not captured in the survey, so I can't say for sure how opinions differ.  Some demographic statistics can be mapped on the census website, and there definitely are differences depending on where you live.  I did analyze turnout at one point, and turnout is definitely higher in the wards near the lake.

Steve

November 16, 2008 10:54 PM

Leave a Comment

Please Sign In to post comment.